What if for alpha title they just had another reforge option with it? Like 2 stages or just another option of getting the same results via a different means
I feel the same.
Nah, there’s a guy who pulled 9 cycles of Khan Stage 1. Some people even come back to Stage 1 for a refresher.
Your guess is as good as mine. I still don’t ‘get’ Khan reforged.
1 Like
I personally don’t like the difference between “forging” and “already being reforged”.
I think both perspectives should be part of the one main title in the first place.
The “route to success” and the “embodiement of success” should be both part of one title.
For me, these two different routes are actually both part of the same route.
I think regular KHAN should simply be updated.
Especially with features from Stabilizer, EE and GLM.
1 Like
This thread is not intended to be a critique or discussion of the nature of “Reforged” style titles. Your personal issues and philosophies do not apply to everyone – and I need to make this clear. This is not going to become a WDB situation, where people following various manosphere philosophies tried to essentially sabotage the concept simply because it disagrees with their personal viewpoints. And now, WDB is one of the most popular titles in the catalog.
Case in point:
What does that have to do with the existence of “Khan Reforged?” Put that suggestion in the roadmap for the update of Khan. Let no one tell us that we cannot explore an idea with the community just because it doesn’t fit your personal worldview. EDIT: And being honest and transparent, I’m going to start shadow banning people from threads who can’t understand that not everything has to revolve around their personal ideas.
Those running Emperor Reforged are loving it. Those who are running WDB are getting incredible results. We know what we’re doing.
12 Likes
Then Reforged is not for you. We wrote an entire article about doing a resonance check and if the title doesn’t resonate with you, ignore its existence.
6 Likes
Think of it this way, not sure I might explain properly though.
OG Emperor
Outwardly focused in the sense that you move, you build, you express. Your external reality reflects that of an Emperor, which in turn shapes your inner world.
Emperor Reforged
Inwardly focused in the sense that you actively dig within you to allow the sovereign within you express, and continue to lean more into it.
Either approach will still have both external and internal results, it’s just the way reality works.
Choosing a path
Does the path make the Emperor or was the Emperor always one?
Both cases could be true, it more depends on which approach do you really need to experience right now, for the same of your growth.
7 Likes
If anyone wants to see the proper way to give push back to an idea, props to @Jouissance for his post:
Notice that he started with his personal thoughts, but then moved into a very detailed explanation that goes far beyond “I just don’t like the idea.”
Notice how @Azriel went into great detail about what he’d like to see: Main Idea Thread - "Khan Reforged" - #18 by Azriel
Obviously, no one has to go into this level of detail and we appreciate them doing so, but we are not entertaining “well, my personal philosophy says no” anymore.
7 Likes
Thank you for the explanation.
Anyway I’ll be ignoring this thread as it’s not resonating with me. And like others I just makes me more confused and unfocused. To me more titles means more problems lol
So please guys don’t tag me here again lol
Cuz I just don’t get it.
Anyway as Saint said some people want different versions and so if I don’t understand something I should for now ignore it so… Yeah I’ll focus on my stack for now.
Ok
1 Like
A small percentage of “others.”
Back on topic, everyone.
Now, to virtually refresh this conversation. Let us state Subliminal Club’s position. We are not in favor of multiple Reforged titles. @Jouissance hit it on the nail in many ways, but @Azriel also posted some very compelling ideas.
If there is a “Khan Reforged” of some sort (you can also recommend things like custom modules and the such), it would most likely take the form of a “stage” within Khan.
The goal of this thread is to determine whether this is even necessary and what would the differentiation between Khan and Khan Reforged even is.
Is it just Khan, turned completely inward? Given that Khan and Emperor overlap so much, I don’t see the necessity of “Khan Reforged,” when Emperor Reforged could achieve the same goal. And I actually agree with the notion of less SKUs = less confusion.
Hence the point of the thread. It is not about personal viewpoint, but collective need. So, is there a need? I say – I don’t think so, I think Emperor: Reforged can serve as the single title for those who want to explore the Reforged concept and then progress to OG Emperor, Khan, Primal, whatever.
But I don’t want the voices of the naysayers to drown out the voices of those who do want to see this.
9 Likes
Emperor Reforged is enough then
What might be worth creating is a support article outlining the path (I think more roadmaps of the titles would be useful in general for those who are confused)
Most of the confusion in this thread and others I am seeing (which one do I need, why a different version) is a positioning question, not a product one
Something like this to reduce confusion (Claude-drafted, illustrative only):
Summary
Choosing Your Path: Forging vs. Reforged
Since the release of Emperor: Reforged, the most common question we receive is some version of: “What’s the difference between this and OG Emperor, and which one do I need?” Fair question. The copy describes the destination, but most of you are trying to choose a starting point. This article is about that choice.
Two pathways, one destination
Every title in the alpha line ultimately points at the same thing: a man whose internal state and external results are congruent. The difference between the OG titles and Reforged is not the destination. It is the direction of travel.
The OG titles — Emperor, Khan, Ascension, Primal — are forging pathways. They assume the structure isn’t built yet. They generate drive, push you into action, and let the identity form through what you build, survive, and conquer. You become the Emperor by doing what Emperors do, until one day you notice you stopped pretending.
Reforged is a recognition pathway. It assumes the structure is already there — built through years of work, struggle, or simply who you’ve always been — but buried under proving, performing, and the suspicion that none of it counts yet. Reforged doesn’t push you to build more. It removes the layer that prevents you from inhabiting what’s built.
Both pathways produce external results. Both produce internal change. That’s just how reality works. The question is which direction of travel you need right now.
How to tell which you need
Don’t choose based on which copy sounds better. Reforged copy sounds better to almost everyone — “you already are powerful” is a more pleasant sentence than “get to work.” That preference tells you nothing. Instead, look at your pattern honestly:
You likely need a forging title if: your life lacks structure you genuinely haven’t built yet. You haven’t tested yourself. The discomfort you feel around status, money, or women comes from real skill and experience gaps, not from discounting what you’ve done. When you achieve something, it lands — you just haven’t achieved enough of it yet.
You likely need Reforged if: you’ve built, achieved, and improved for years, and the goalposts keep moving. Wins don’t land. You perform competence rather than rest in it. Your effort works but never produces settledness — there’s always one more thing to fix before you’re allowed to feel like him. If that describes you, more forging will not solve it. You’ll just build a bigger kingdom to feel inadequate inside of.
If you’re genuinely unsure, run the resonance check from our earlier article. The forging titles tend to resonate as hunger. Reforged tends to resonate as relief.
Where Reforged sits in the progression
There is one Reforged title, and that’s deliberate. Reforged is not a parallel product line — it’s an entry point and a recalibration point for the entire alpha catalog:
Run Emperor: Reforged when recognition is the bottleneck. Then progress to OG Emperor, Khan, Primal, or wherever your goals point, and build from a foundation that doesn’t need the building to prove anything. Some of you will return to Reforged between major titles the way others return to Regeneration — not because you regressed, but because each new level of building can reactivate the old proving pattern at a higher altitude.
You do not need a Reforged version of every title. The recognition work is the same work regardless of which empire you build afterward. One door in. Many directions out.
3 Likes
When I think of an Inner Khan, I think of something that continues the self-mastery trend of GLM. Master yourself before you master the world. I feel a ‘reforging’ stage could fit nicely between TB and Reprogramming.
1 Like
Sorry if my suggestion was out of topic.
Just to illustrate that I understand both sides, while this is a good idea – do we need a new SKU to achieve it? Why not just do a short run of GLM? That’s the question that we have to answer as subliminal producers. Is it necessary?
With this idea – if even @Fire said this to me – my immediate response would be: well, now we need to differentiate the Khan Reforged idea against GLM.
Now, not talking to you directly on this next point, just giving everyone a bit more insight.
It’s a very nuanced situation, and I apologize if people think that I am being aggressive – but, you’re not wrong. I am. @Fire and I call this process, “The Crucible,” and everyone’s actually seeing a very tame version of it.
When either one of us presents an idea, we have trained ourselves to pretty much beat the shit out of that idea, to force it into a state of refinement, and it is exactly how we have developed such potent titles. Because every title goes through a long stage of debate, refinement, debate, refinement – sometimes, tossing the entire idea and starting over.
The underlying philosophy here is that an idea should be able to withstand incredible pressure. If it survives the process, it is a solid idea and title. If the idea collapses under the weight of pressure, it wasn’t a good idea.
This concept has served us well, as we can see. With Khan Reforged, I am not sure it can withstand the rigor of The Crucible. Emperor Reforged barely made it through. We have a ton of unfinished and unmade titles that are just sitting there, since the idea seems to fall apart under scrutiny.
And so, even in the idea threads, we have to subject the ideas to a smaller version of the same creative process. Be frustrated with us if you want, but I don’t think anyone can deny that it is effective in the long run.
So, for “Khan Reforged,” what makes this title unique? Why would we need a new SKU just for this? Honestly, I would do a “Primal Seduction Reforged” type title over a Khan Reforged, since Khan has a lot of wealth and drive in it, overlapping with Emperor and the other wealth-alpha titles. But the hard seduction titles? I honestly think that’s the better path, but it would have to undergo the same refinement process.
16 Likes
Yes please. Kidding, don’t hurt me lol.
3 Likes
Oh no, I agree. Even as a major proponent of inward titles, I’m at a loss with how to differentiate Khan Reforged from GLM or even Emperor reforged
2 Likes
Will Chosen from Within become Chosen Reforged?
If a new concept is too close to existing ones it kinda carries the danger (especially with the urge for instant gratification) that a lot of people will hop onto the new train (half justified because new tech) often hoping for better results when in most cases carrying on with the current stack would bring the best results.
Maybe we could implement something like The Crucible on the Roadmap? It could help to develop ideas, see what people want on here.
4 Likes
Lmao, check PM if you want a good laugh
1 Like
Now, that’s a very interesting idea.
7 Likes